Final portfolio parts with grading criteria

Part 1 Reflection

Include multiple artifacts to demonstrate the qualities below. (Put in first 2-pocket folder.)

  • Thorough
  • Thoughtful
  • Honest
  • Forward thinking, as well as backward assessing

Part 2: Process

Include multiple artifacts to demonstrate the qualities in the chart below. (Put in second 2-pocket folder.)

  • Quantity of artifacts shows engagement with process
  • Quality of work shows a “good faith” effort: e.g. risk-taking, “get-and-give” attitude, openness, concentrated effort, work that’s more than perfunctory (“I’m doing the minimum I can get away with and only because it’s an assignment”)
  • Meets deadlines: work done consistently on time.

Part 3: WOVE Products

(Put in third 2-pocket folder.)

3.1 Written compositions

Include at least 2 chosen from Comp 1-5 to demonstrate the qualities below.

Context
  • Involves reader early
  • Gives clear sense of question, problem, or motivation behind the composition
  • Establishes a clear relationship between the writer and situation
Substance
  • Includes detailed examples to develop ideas
  • Focuses on suitably narrowed subject
  • Uses facts and other kinds of evidence responsibly
  • Gives precise definitions of key terminology
Organization
  • Has clear thesis/claim
  • Structured to present an overall coherent argument
  • Contains well-developed, unified, coherent paragraphs that avoid being rigidly formulaic
  • Uses transitions within and between paragraphs to clarify logic and purpose of ideas
  • Contains audience-oriented headings when appropriate
Style
  • Uses verbal expression (voice and language) suited to the audience and situation, including precise, meaningful wording; a preference for active, rather than passive and other “to be” verbs; and only purposeful repetition
  • Adheres to appropriate usage, punctuation, and grammar conventions
  • Shows careful proofreading and documenting

3.2.1 Oral Communication: Small-group work and group discussions

Include multiple artifacts to supplement instructor observation and to demonstrate the qualities below.

Context
  • Uses team thinking
  • Listens actively
  • Offers constructive comments, intelligent questions
Substance
  • Recognizes other team members’ ideas
Organization
  • Summarizes actions or issues at key decision points
  • Helps develop productive procedures
Style
  • Uses motivating, non-threatening, directive, relationship-building language
Delivery
  • Exhibits clear, interested voice, gestures, facial expression, eye contact with team members

3.2.2 Oral Communication: Presentations

Include multiple artifacts to supplement instructor observation (and possibly videotaping) and to demonstrate the qualities below.

Context
  • Shows a clear purpose
  • Uses an appropriate level of formality
  • Considers audience needs
Substance
  • Includes substantive, worthwhile, audience-oriented content
Organization
  • Creates clear logic through use of introductions and conclusions, repetition, cueing, enumeration, etc.
Style
  • Maintains audience attention through language choices suited to the oral situation
Delivery
  • Shows attention to volume, gestures, eye contact, facial expression, posture, etc.

3.3 Visual Communication

Include 1 or more artifacts to demonstrate the qualities below.

Context
  • Creates a holistic visual impression to fit the situation
  • Quickly communicates overall purpose
  • Provides rich supporting detail
Substance
  • Includes informative, relevant, reliable visuals
  • Uses decorative and/or informational images as appropriate
  • Has a meaningful title/heading
  • Shows cultural sensitivity
Organization
  • Creates clear visual patterns with purposeful variations
  • Guides viewer eye movements through adherence to accepted design principles
  • Uses visual chunking to match emphasis and function
  • Maintains a consistent visual theme
Style
  • Achieves clear, purposeful foreground-background contrast
  • Selects appropriate graphic style, typography, and color
  • Documents sources
  • Headings are logically and grammatically parallel
Delivery
  • Shows audience/user-based technical decisions about color, resolution, size, luminance, format, sharpness, etc.
  • Crops images concisely and achieves a polished, professional-looking appearance

3.4 Electronic Communication

Include 1 or more artifacts to demonstrate either or both of the qualities below.

  • Effective use of electronic communication mode
  • Effective composing in the electronic mode